Changeset - f5ecf753baaa
[Not reviewed]
0 2 1
Bradley M. Kuhn - 13 months ago 2021-10-19 17:05:26
bkuhn@sfconservancy.org
Copyleft Compliance — Vizio — initial announcement
3 files changed with 147 insertions and 1 deletions:
0 comments (0 inline, 0 general)
www/conservancy/static/copyleft-compliance/vizio.html
Show inline comments
 
new file 100644
 
{% extends "base_compliance.html" %}
 
{% block subtitle %}Copyleft Compliance Projects - {% endblock %}
 
{% block submenuselection %}Vizio{% endblock %}
 
{% block content %}
 

	
 
<h1>Software Freedom Conservancy files lawsuit against California TV manufacturer Vizio Inc. for GPL violations</h1>
 
<h2>Litigation is historic in nature due to its focus on consumer rights, filing as third-party beneficiary</h2>
 

	
 
<p><strong>FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE</strong></p>
 

	
 
<p>IRVINE, Calif. (Oct. 19, 2021) Software Freedom Conservancy announced today
 
it has filed a lawsuit against Vizio Inc. for what it calls repeated failures
 
to fulfill even the basic requirements of the General Public License (GPL).</p>
 

	
 

	
 
<p>The lawsuit alleges that Vizio’s TV products, built on its SmartCast system,
 
contain software that Vizio unfairly appropriated from a community of
 
developers who intended consumers to have very specific rights to modify,
 
improve, share, and reinstall modified versions of the software.</p>
 

	
 

	
 
<p>The GPL is a copyleft license that ensures end users the freedom to run,
 
study, share, and modify the software. Copyleft is a kind of software
 
licensing that leverages the restrictions of copyright, but with the intent
 
to promote sharing (using copyright licensing to freely use and repair
 
software).</p>
 

	
 
<p>Software Freedom Conservancy, a nonprofit organization focused on ethical
 
technology, is filing the lawsuit as the purchaser of a product which has
 
copylefted code. This approach makes it the first legal case that focuses on
 
the rights of individual consumers as third-party beneficiaries of the GPL.
 

	
 
<p>&ldquo;That’s what makes this litigation unique and historic in terms of
 
defending consumer rights,&rdquo; says Karen M. Sandler, the organization’s
 
executive director.</p>
 

	
 

	
 
<p>According to the lawsuit, a consumer of a product such as this has the
 
right to access the source code so that it can be modified, studied, and
 
redistributed (under the appropriate license conditions).</p>
 

	
 

	
 

	
 
<p>&ldquo;We are asking the court to require Vizio to make good on its
 
  obligations under copyleft compliance requirements,&rdquo; says
 
  Sandler. She explains that in past litigation, the plaintiffs have always
 
  been copyright holders of the specific GPL code. In this case, Software
 
  Freedom Conservancy hopes to demonstrate that it's not just the copyright
 
  holders, but also the receivers of the licensed code who are entitled to
 
  rights.</p>
 

	
 
<p>The lawsuit suit seeks no monetary damages, but instead seeks access to
 
the technical information that the copyleft licenses require Vizio to provide
 
to all customers who purchase its TVs (specifically, the plaintiff is asking
 
for the technical information via &ldquo;specific performance&rdquo; rather
 
than &ldquo;damages&rdquo;).</p>
 

	
 

	
 
<p>&ldquo;Software Freedom Conservancy is standing up for customers who are
 
  alienated and exploited by the technology on which they increasingly
 
  rely,&rdquo; says Sandler, adding that the lawsuit also aims to help
 
  educate consumers about their right to repair their devices as well as show
 
  policy makers that there are mechanisms for corporate accountability
 
  already in place that can be leveraged through purchasing power and
 
  collective action.</p>
 

	
 

	
 
<p>Copyleft licensing was designed as an ideological alternative to the
 
classic corporate software model because it: allows people who receive the
 
software to fix their devices, improve them and control them; entitles people
 
to curtail surveillance and ads; and helps people continue to use their
 
devices for a much longer time (instead of being forced to purchase new
 
ones).</p>
 

	
 

	
 
<p>&ldquo;The global supply chain shortages that have affected everything
 
from cars to consumer electronics underscore one of the reasons why it is
 
important to be able to repair products we already own,&rdquo; says
 
Sandler. &ldquo;Even without supply chain challenges, the forced obsolescence
 
of devices like TVs isn’t in the best interest of the consumer or even the
 
planet. This is another aspect of what we mean by &lsquo;ethical
 
technology.&rsquo; Throwing away a TV because its software is no longer
 
supported by its manufacturer is not only wasteful, it has dire environmental
 
consequences. Consumers should have more control over this, and they would if
 
companies like Vizio played by the rules.&ldquo;</p>
 

	
 

	
 
<p>According to Sandler, the organization first raised the issue of
 
non-compliance with the GPL with Vizio in August 2018. After a year of
 
diplomatic attempts to work with the company, it was not only still refusing
 
to comply, but stopped responding to inquiries altogether as of January 2020.</p>
 

	
 

	
 
<p>&ldquo;By July 2021, the TV model that we originally complained was
 
non-compliant was discontinued,” says Sandler. “When we purchased new models,
 
we found that despite our efforts they still had no source code included with
 
the device, nor any offer for source code. People buying these models would
 
never know that there was anything special about the software in these
 
devices, or that they had any rights whatsoever connected with the software
 
on their TVs.&rdquo;</p>
 

	
 

	
 
<p>Software Freedom Conservancy analyzed the TVs and concluded that not only
 
was Vizio not providing the source code and technical information that
 
copyleft licenses require, Vizio was not even informing its customers about
 
copylefted software and the rights it gives them as consumers.</p>
 

	
 

	
 
<h3>ABOUT SOFTWARE FREEDOM CONSERVANCY</h3>
 

	
 

	
 
<p>Software Freedom Conservancy is a nonprofit organization centered around
 
ethical technology. Our mission is to ensure the right to repair, improve,
 
and reinstall software. We promote and defend these rights through fostering
 
free and open source software (FOSS) projects, driving initiatives that
 
actively make technology more inclusive, and advancing policy strategies that
 
defend FOSS (such as copyleft). The organization is incorporated in New
 
York. For more information, go
 
to <a href="https://sfconservancy.org">sfconservancy.org</a>.</p>
 

	
 

	
 

	
 
<h3>SUPPLEMENTAL RESOURCES FOR JOURNALISTS</h3>
 

	
 

	
 
<p><a href="https://sfconservancy.org/docs/software-freedom-conservancy-v-vizio-announce-press-kit.pdf">A
 
full press kit, with substantial additional information and resources for
 
journalists covering this story, can be viewed and downloaded here</a>.
 

	
 
<h3>MEDIA CONTACT</h3>
 

	
 
<p>Hannah Gregory, Media Rep for Good Causes<br/>
 
<a href="mailto:media@sfconservancy.org">&ldquo;media@sfconservancy.org&rdquo;</a>, 914-960-4642</p>
 
{% endblock %}
www/conservancy/static/css/conservancy.css
Show inline comments
...
 
@@ -376,6 +376,7 @@ body > header {
 
#container #sidebar.Services ul li.Services,
 
#container #sidebar.Applying ul li.Applying,
 
#container #sidebar.PastLawsuits ul li.PastLawsuits,
 
#container #sidebar.Vizio ul li.Vizio,
 
#container #sidebar.CopyleftPrinciples ul li.CopyleftPrinciples,
 
#container #sidebar.AboutCompliance ul li.AboutCompliance,
 
#container #sidebar.HelpComply ul li.HelpComply,
www/conservancy/templates/base_compliance.html
Show inline comments
...
 
@@ -13,7 +13,18 @@
 
         <div id="sidebar" class="{% block submenuselection %}other{% endblock %}">
 
            <h2>What We Do</h2>
 
            {% include 'submenus/what_we_do_partial.html' %}
 
            <h2>Our Copyleft {% block category %}Compliance{% endblock %} Projects</h2>
 
            <h2>Vizio Lawsuit</h2>
 
            <ul>
 
            <li class="Vizio"><a href="/copyleft-compliance/vizio.html">Vizio Lawsuit</a></li>
 
            <li class="Vizio"><a href="/press/qanda.html">Q&amp;A</a></li>
 
            </ul>
 
            <h2>Resources for Journalists On Vizio</h2>
 
            <ul>
 
            <li class="PressKit"><a href="/docs/software-freedom-conservancy-v-vizio-announce-press-kit.pdf">Press Kit</a></li>
 
            <li class="PressKit"><a href="/docs/software-freedom-conservancy-v-vizio-photo-assets.zip">Photo Assets</a></li>
 
            <li class="Glossary"><a href="/copyleft-compliance/glossary.html">Glossary</a></li>
 
            </ul>
 
            <h2>More About Copyleft Compliance&hellip;</h2>
 
            <ul>
 
            <li class="AboutCompliance"><a href="/copyleft-compliance/about.html">About</a></li>
 
            <li class="HelpComply"><a href="/copyleft-compliance/help.html">How To Help</a></li>
0 comments (0 inline, 0 general)