diff --git a/gpl-lgpl.tex b/gpl-lgpl.tex index 291998ef638919e808f8293224e8a8d3860c1194..40439132f631a4d7ac36f6a5ac855e2faf94dc9b 100644 --- a/gpl-lgpl.tex +++ b/gpl-lgpl.tex @@ -3846,7 +3846,19 @@ Instead, GPLv3~\S11\P3--5 are specifically concerned with explicit promises that are purportedly legally enforceable. Nevertheless, unlike traditional commercial patent licensing -agreements\footnote{FIXME: note such a clause is rare, if not unique.}, +agreements\footnote{Typically, well-drafted commercial patent license + agreements explicitly exclude any possibility of + implied licenses. Thus, GPLv3's final paragraph may be unique among both commercial + agreements and/or other Free Software licenses (both copyleft and + non-copyleft). Careful study of the patent licensing implications of GPL + should not ignore this observation. In particular, contrast carefully the + goals of commercial patent licensing agreements and the policy goals of a + copyleft license. Namely, patent license granters typically draft patent license + to explicitly license only a narrow set of patents. However, FSF sought to assure + patent licenses for all Free Software users, redistributors, and developers. + While GPLv3\S11 undoubtedly contains some compromises regarding explicit + patent licensing, FSF did not compromise on bringing forward GPLv2's + existing implicit patent license.}, rather than confining the patent license grant to some narrow set of such express situations, GPLv3 preserves the \hyperref[gpl-implied-patent-grant]{existing implied patent licensing structure}