Changeset - 8bd2bbc58d27
[Not reviewed]
0 1 0
Bradley Kuhn (bkuhn) - 10 years ago 2014-03-21 16:53:56
bkuhn@ebb.org
Wrote and merged text for GPLv3ยง12
1 file changed with 14 insertions and 14 deletions:
0 comments (0 inline, 0 general)
gpl-lgpl.tex
Show inline comments
...
 
@@ -3561,30 +3561,30 @@ distinguish pernicious deals of the Microsoft/Novell type from
 
business conduct that is not particularly harmful, the FSF also did not
 
assume success in that drafting, and thus there remained some risk that other
 
unchangeable past agreements could fall within the  scope of GPLv3~\S11\P7.
 
In future deals, distributors engaging in ordinary business practices
 
can structure the agreements so that they do not fall under GPLv3~\S11\P7.
 

	
 
\section{GPLv3~\S12: Familiar as GPLv2 \S~7}
 
\section{GPLv3~\S12: Familiar as GPLv2~\S7}
 

	
 
% FIXME:  probably mostly still right, needs some updates, though.
 

	
 
The wording in the first sentence of section 12 has been revised
 
slightly to clarify that an agreement, such as a litigation settlement
 
agreement or a patent license agreement, is one of the ways in which
 
conditions may be ``imposed'' on a GPL licensee that may contradict the
 
conditions of the GPL, but which do not excuse the licensee from
 
compliance with those conditions.  This change codifies what has been
 
our interpretation of GPLv2.  
 
GPLv2~\S12 remains almost completely unchanged from the text that appears
 
GPLv2~\S7.  This is an important provision that ensures a catch-all to ensure
 
that nothing ``surprising'' interferes with the continued conveyance safely
 
under copyleft.
 

	
 
% FIXME:  probably mostly still right, needs some updates, though.
 
The wording in the first sentence of GPLv3~\S12 has been revised slightly to
 
clarify that an agreement -- such as a litigation settlement agreement or a
 
patent license agreement -- is one of the ways in which conditions may be
 
``imposed'' on a GPL licensee that may contradict the conditions of the GPL,
 
but which do not excuse the licensee from compliance with those conditions.
 
This change codifies the historical interpretation of GPLv2.
 

	
 
We have removed the limited severability clause of GPLv2 section 7 as a
 
GPLv3 removed the limited severability clause of GPLv2~\S7 as a
 
matter of tactical judgment, believing that this is the best way to ensure
 
that all provisions of the GPL will be upheld in court. We have also removed
 
the final sentence of GPLv2 section 7, which we consider to be unnecessary.
 
that all provisions of the GPL will be upheld in court. GPLv3 also removed
 
the final sentence of GPLv2 section 7, which the FSF consider to be unnecessary.
 

	
 
\section{GPLv3~\S13: The Great Affero Compromise}
 

	
 
The main purpose of clause 7b4 was to attain GPLv3 compatibility for the
 
additional condition of version 1 of the Affero GPL, with a view to
 
achieving compatibility for a future version, since version 1 was
0 comments (0 inline, 0 general)